Ebenezer, Paramount's version of A Christmas Carol directed by Ti West, opened at number one with $19.0 million from 3,535 theaters, according to The Numbers. That is $5,375 per theater. The bigger story of the weekend is further down the chart: Godzilla Minus Zero, which earned an A from audiences, fell 73% in its second weekend.
The Chart
Per The Numbers, for the weekend of November 13:
| Rank | Film | Weekend | Change | Theaters | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ebenezer | $19.0M | New | 3,535 | $19.0M |
| 2 | The Cat in the Hat | $11.4M | −43% | 4,003 | $38.2M |
| 3 | Godzilla Minus Zero | $8.3M | −73% | 3,246 | $48.9M |
| 4 | Ramayana: Rise of a Legend | $5.5M | −38% | 1,110 | $24.1M |
| 5 | You Can See Everything | $5.5M | −35% | 1,845 | $89.0M |
| 6 | Ghost Soldier | $5.2M | New | 2,558 | $8.3M |
| 7 | How to Rob a Bank | $5.2M | New | 2,810 | $5.2M |
| 8 | Wild Horse Nine | $4.6M | −22% | 2,175 | $13.3M |
| 9 | Wildwood | $4.4M | −40% | 2,173 | $48.3M |
| 10 | Clayface | $3.7M | −45% | 2,284 | $63.6M |
The chart lists 39 films with a combined $86.0 million. The Numbers does not label these figures as estimates, but weekend figures posted this early are often revised. Our own second-weekend numbers for Clayface were revised that way, as we note in our updated piece on it. Ghost Soldier, from Sony, opened on Wednesday, so its $8.3 million total covers five days.
Ebenezer: First Place, Mixed Reviews
- Opening: $19.0 million domestic. Wikipedia lists $42 million worldwide for the opening weekend.
- Budget: $38 million, per Wikipedia. The domestic opening alone is half of that.
- Audience: an A− CinemaScore.
- Critics: 54% on Rotten Tomatoes from 123 reviews (average 5.6 out of 10) and 46 on Metacritic from 37 critics, as of November 14 and 15.
- Cast: Johnny Depp as Scrooge, with Rupert Grint, Ian McKellen, Daisy Ridley and Sam Claflin.
An A− with a 54% critics' score is a split verdict, and the second weekend will show which side holds more weight.
Godzilla Minus Zero: A Grade, Steep Drop
Godzilla Minus Zero opened to $30.6 million on November 6 from 3,254 theaters, a $9,415 average, according to The Numbers. This weekend it earned $8.3 million from 3,246 theaters. Per Wikipedia, it has an A CinemaScore, 91% on Rotten Tomatoes from 194 reviews, and a reported budget of $13 to $18 million.
Our CinemaScore explainer suggested that audience grades roughly track staying power. Here is where the second weekend of each film we have tracked landed, ordered from best to worst:
| Film | CinemaScore | Second-weekend change |
|---|---|---|
| Obsession | A− | +39% |
| Wildwood | A | −27% |
| The Cat in the Hat | A | −43% |
| Clayface | A− | −54% |
| Resident Evil | B+ | −62% |
| Verity | C+ | −63% |
| Other Mommy | D+ | −70% |
| Godzilla Minus Zero | A | −73% |
| Scream 7 | B− | −73% |
All changes come from The Numbers' weekend charts and film pages, checked on November 16. Wildwood's figure is measured against its $12.3 million opening-weekend number, which includes Thursday previews.
An A-graded film sits next to the bottom. Two things are worth noting.
The opening was concentrated. Wikipedia, citing Deadline, says $21.3 million of the $30.6 million opening came from IMAX, about 70%. A premium-format opening driven by fans tends to arrive all at once. That is our reading of the pattern, not something any source states about this film.
It was not a loss of theaters. The theater count barely moved, 3,254 to 3,246, so the drop did not come from the film being pulled from screens. We cannot see how many of those were IMAX.
For a film with a $13 to $18 million budget, the drop matters less than the total. The Numbers has $48.9 million domestic after ten days. Worldwide totals disagree in Wikipedia's own article: $80 million in its text (from The Numbers, November 14) and $105 million in its infobox (from Deadline, November 15). We do not treat either as settled. Both are several times the budget.
Wild Horse Nine: A Gentler Slope
Wild Horse Nine, Martin McDonagh's Searchlight film, opened to $5.9 million from 1,100 theaters ($5,369 per theater) and fell 22% to $4.6 million. Its total is $13.3 million.
That drop is smaller than most of the chart, but it came with a wider release: the film nearly doubled its theaters, from 1,100 to 2,175, so the average per theater fell from about $5,400 to about $2,100. Reviews are strong: 94% on Rotten Tomatoes from 249 reviews and 77 on Metacritic from 51 critics, per Wikipedia. We found no CinemaScore. Wikipedia lists a $13 to $15 million budget and $28 million worldwide. We covered the reviews before release in our roundup.
The Rest of the Chart
- The Cat in the Hat fell 43% to $38.2 million domestic. Wikipedia lists a budget of $86 to $92 million and $56 million worldwide as of November 15, with an A CinemaScore and 47% on Rotten Tomatoes.
- How to Rob a Bank opened to $5.2 million from 2,810 theaters.
- Wildwood has $48.3 million after 24 days, and Clayface has $63.6 million after 24 days.
Editorial Take: The audience grade is still the best early read on whether a crowd liked a film, but this weekend showed its limit. An A means the people who came were happy. It does not say how many more are coming. Godzilla Minus Zero got the grade and used up most of its audience in opening weekend, probably because that audience came early and for premium screens. Wildwood, with the same A, drew a smaller crowd and kept it. The better question to ask of a grade is how front-loaded the opening was. A drop of 73% is also less alarming on a film that cost $13 to $18 million, and Godzilla Minus Zero has already earned several times that.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was number one at the box office this weekend? Ebenezer, with $19.0 million from 3,535 theaters, per The Numbers.
How much did Godzilla Minus Zero make in its second weekend? $8.3 million, down 73% from its $30.6 million opening. It has $48.9 million domestically.
What is Godzilla Minus Zero's CinemaScore? A, per Wikipedia citing Deadline.
What are the Ebenezer reviews? 54% on Rotten Tomatoes from 123 reviews and 46 on Metacritic from 37 critics. Audiences gave it an A− CinemaScore.
How much did Ebenezer cost? $38 million, per Wikipedia.
Is Wild Horse Nine doing well? It fell 22% to $4.6 million and has $13.3 million domestically against a reported $13 to $15 million budget, with a 94% Rotten Tomatoes score.
Box office and review figures come from the sources linked above and can change. Tracking what arrives next across movies, TV, games, music and books at incoming.to.